It’s Christmas time in Prescott! But someone’s Christmas lights will be extinguished forever!

Sarah Sharpe and the Broken Dishes crew are preparing for the Christmas season. Broken Dishes is filled to the brim with holiday decor, gifts, and boxes of sweet treats from The Crumb Factory.

The holiday season could not be going any better. But then Thea and Sarah have a major disagreement, Nate keeps a big secret from Sarah, and Mayor Whitlock dies unexpectedly.

When Sarah’s friends at The Crumb Factory are accused of playing a part in Mayor Whitlock’s death, Sarah is put in a difficult position. She tries her best to focus on being a good manager at Broken Dishes, but once again Sarah Sharpe must put on her amateur sleuth cap in order to solve the mystery behind the mayor’s death.